Technology to Replace Interpreters, Could this Lead To A Miscarriage of Justice?
Early June saw the annual Sir Henry Brooke lecture delivered by Lord Burnett of Maldon on 'the age of reform'. Lord Burnett said he had 'little doubt' that high-quality simultaneous translation will be available and 'see the end of interpreters'.
The Institute of Translation and Interpreting however, says Burnett's prediction is based unproven assumptions. The Institute's chair, Sarah Griffin Mason and Chief Executive, Jonathan Downie wrote to Burnett stating that "technologies that underlie automatic simultaneous interpreting, such as speech recognition, are a long way from being perfected".
They also stated "Even the most highly developed machine translation systems can and do commit errors at a rate that would be unacceptable for the judicial process... To allow such systems loose on the justice system in their current state and without significant time in testing, development and trialling would lead to miscarriages of justice, increased taxpayer expense and the inability of those with limited English proficiency to participate in the justice system. This runs counter to current human rights law and would lead to irreparable damage to the British justice system.'
The institute's views are echoed by Alan Thompson, chair of the Association of Police and Court Interpreters. Thompson told the Gazette:
'The concept of a universal translator - a "black box" which can translate speech from one language into another - is of course nothing new; my recollection is that such a device was in use as early as the 1960s by the crew of the Starship Enterprise to enable them to communicate readily with any alien species they might encounter. Of course, back then it was pure science fiction, but the march of technology has brought the fiction much closer to reality'.
'However, recent experience with machine translation has shown that there is a vast gulf between a draft quality translation of a text, sufficient to enable the reader to grasp its general meaning, and an accurate, faithful and idiomatic rendition provided by a professional linguist. In proceedings so much can hang on the precise translation of the meaning of a single word, with all its nuances, and for now only a professional interpreter can provide that.'
Mason and Downie say, "The systems for hiring, briefing and working with courtroom interpreters are overdue for improvement. 'Given your concern for interpreting to be provided in an accurate and efficient manner, we would therefore like to invite you to come and meet with some of our legal interpreter members to hear their views directly. This would allow you to lead change and create precisely the kind of reactive, efficient interpreting system you desire,' their letter concludes".
To discuss any legal matters please contact our Pemberton Team on Tel: 01942 366 388
Allansons Solicitors
Pemberton
Get in touch
with your query or requirements
Pemberton Solicitors
From our offices in Wigan, our experienced solicitors can assist with a wide variety of legal needs, including;
Commercial law, residential and commercial conveyancing, personal injury claims and Wills and probate.
Call our team in complete confidence to discuss your needs.
Contact
Allansons Solicitors,
685 Ormskirk Road,
Pemberton,
Wigan,
Lancashire,
WN5 8AQ
0845 603 0708
685 Ormskirk Road,
Pemberton,
Wigan,
Lancashire,
WN5 8AQ
0845 603 0708